According to John Wills Lloyd of Teach Effectively as he comments on the D-Ed Reckoning site,
For those who trust their intuition more than scientific evidence, learning styles are alive and well.
For those of you who are ready to stop believing and want the proof in the name of “good teaching” there is some pretty compelling evidence here , here and here.
According to Professor Dan T. Willingham maker of the rapidly rising “Learning Styles Don’t Exist” You Tube video, teachers should forget about centering instruction on student learning styles and instead;
1. Teach for content meaning
He writes in his research,
An important finding from that research is that memory is usually stored independent of any modality. You typically store memories in terms of meaning—not in terms of whether you saw, heard, or physically interacted with the information.
2. Where appropriate teach to the content’s best modality
He also notes,
Experiences in different modalities simply for the sake of including different modalities should not be the goal. Material should be presented auditorily or visually because the information that the teacher wants students to understand is best conveyed in that modality.
In addition, John Wills Lloyd also comments on D-Ed Reckoning that,
Doubting learning styles is not the equivalent of saying “one size fits all.”
and he reminds us that non believers in learning styles actually,
favor adapting instruction for individual learners.
His post on Teach Effectively uses snazzy graphs to illustrate that if you really want to be a “good teacher” and have your lessons have the most powerful impact on your students then tailor your instruction to following:
3. Using formative assessment to guide instruction over any type of student based Learning Style theory
4. Combining formative assessment guided instruction with behavior modification techniques

So Virginia how do you want to teach, intuitively or effectively ?



He hit it right on the nail when he mentioned formative assessments!
By the way, thanks for your encouraging comment on my blog
By: Sarah on August 28, 2008
at 6:35 pm
He sure did! I had concerns about Willingham’s video that I had outlined in my previous posts but the supplemental information that I’ve been able to gather through the sources above definitely made things clearer about what Willingham and his supporters define as “good teaching.”
And yw, I’ve been there when you think you’re doing the right thing and it backfires because someone else isn’t happy about it. It’s a hard position but all you can do is just keep moving forward.
By: AwayWeGo! on August 28, 2008
at 7:13 pm
I’ve got to admit, I sometimes do a little of both! But I do agree that practice makes perfect, which is why formative assessments are such a great tool. BTW, drop by tomorrow for another crazy edition of Silly Sunday Sweepstakes. Come Share the Comment Love!
By: Melissa B. on August 31, 2008
at 8:18 am
AwayWeGo
I just found your posts. . .If you have questions, by all means, email me w/ clarification questions! I always try to respond. . .
by the way, most of the early studies on learning styles were conducted with LD kids.
Dan
By: Dan Willingham on September 6, 2008
at 2:02 am
Dan, thank you so much for your response and your offer of email clarifications.
I had noticed a comment in one of the blogs that the LD kids were included in the initial studies, thank you for pointing it out again here.
By: AwayWeGo! on September 6, 2008
at 2:23 am